Skip to main content

Table 3 Summary of crosslinking modes and properties of natural and synthetic polymer hydrogel scaffolds

From: Ultramodern natural and synthetic polymer hydrogel scaffolds for articular cartilage repair and regeneration

Component

Crosslinking method

Strength

Hydration properties

Degradation rate

Aperture/porosity

References

Col/PDA/HA

Freeze drying

800 kPa

  

200 μm

[40]

HAMA/4-Arm PEG-ACLT

3D bio-printing; UV irradiation

    

[45]

GCS/DF-PEG

Self-healing

33.19 kPa

 

18.3%

200–400 μm

[48]

CS-alginate + HAp

TIPS

98–270 MPa

  

2.93 ± 1.63 × 104 μm2

[49]

SH/GO/CS/nHAP

Upper layer SH (EDC and NHS); upper layer CS/GO (ultrasonicated); SH/GO/CS/nHAP(freeze-dried)

Upper layer (0.28 ± 0.024 MPa); upper layer (0.38 ± 0.021 MPa)

High water absorption

15.1%

The upper layer (40–200 µm); the lower layer (30–100 µm)

[50]

CS-KGN/OSA

Room-temperature self-crosslinking

300 kPa

The water content is relatively low

7.8%

20 μm

[53]

HAChCS

LDI crosslinking

0.5–0.8 MPa

High water absorption

40 d (40%)

Macroporosity (≈200 μm) and microporosity (≈10 μm)

[54]

Naringin–BG hydrogels

Mix BG/SA solution and naringin/AG/SA solution

    

[58]

OSA–DA

Schiff base reduction method and oxidation of NaIO4

    

[62]

US–SF

Ultrasonication

90.95–6.04 kPa

High water absorption

28 d (30%)

Porosity of 86%

[73]

MCS/MSF

UV irradiation

0.32 ± 0.07 MPa

8.79 ± 0.71

 

The porosity is slightly smaller

[75]

PEG [PRGF]

PRGF (freeze thawing); PEG [PRGF] (Room-temperature incubation)

  

9–10 d

 

[86]

PEGDA + GelMA/Alginate

Layered 3D printing PEGDA; PEGDA and GelMA/Alginate low-temperature crosslinking

10–14 MPa

High moisture content

 

The surface pore morphology is uniform

[93]

PLGA–g-(PCL5)3

(PLGA + oligo-PCL5) TEG was added and mixed evenly, lyophilization

Greater than 0.60 MPa

 

20% degradation in seven weeks

237 ± 31 μm

[96]

BC–PVA–PAMPS

Freeze thawing; UV irradiation PAMPS

23.0 MPa

   

[101]

PVA–PMEDAH

PVA and PMEDAH mix; Freeze thawing

   

Diameters ranging from 1 μm to 300 nm

[102]

PVA/CS

Freeze thawing

 

The water content is above 85%

 

200–400 μm

[103]

PVA–PAAc

Freeze thawing; annealing

 

Fequilibrium water content 48 ± 2%

  

[104]

  1. CS chitosan, HAp hydroxyapatite, GO graphene oxide, SH sodium hyaluronate, EDC 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl), NHS N-hydroxysuccinimide, TIPS thermally-induced phase separation, KGN kartogenin, OSA aldehyde-modified oxidized alginate, ADH adipic dihydrazide, HACh hyaluronic acid–chitosan scaffolds, LDI l-lysine diisocyanate, BG bioglass, SA sodium alginate, AG agarose, DA dopamine hydrochloride, SF silk fibroin, US ultrasonic, MSF methacrylated silk fibroin, MCS maleilated chitosan, BA benzyl alcohol, TEG triethylene glycol, BC bacterial cellulose, PAMPS poly(2-acrylamido-2-methyl-1-propanesulfonic acid sodium salt), pMEDSAH poly[2-(methacryloyloxy) ethyl] dimethyl-(3-sulfopropyl) ammonium hydroxide), MEDSAH ([2-(methacryloyloxy) ethyl] dimethyl-(3-sulfopropyl) ammonium hydroxide) monomer, PAAc poly(acrylic acid)